Best Weed Barrier Reviews

One of the drawbacks of having a large garden is what seems like endless maintenance.

A lawn is perhaps the most labor-intensive and demanding part of the yard. From making sure the grass is properly fertilized and watered through to mowing it regularly, keeping on top of the lawn is hard work.

Today, we’ll look at some weed barrier reviews to help you in the constant fight against these menacing garden invaders.

If you want your vegetables to retain all their nutrients and your flowers to look their best, the best weed barrier is a smart investment. They are not expensive and will minimize the time you need to spend manually pulling weeds.

This month, we are working on a detailed lawn care guide so you can get the very most out of your garden. For now, though, our focus is purely on those weeds and getting rid of them the easy way…

What Is a Weed Barrier?

If you want to avoid using chemical weed killers, a weed barrier is a worthwhile alternative. Not everyone wants potentially dangerous chemicals leeching into their soil.

The purpose of a weed barrier is to prevent sun, air and water from reaching and nourishing the weeds. You can kill off their life source without needing to resort to chemicals.

Weed barriers generally come as lengthy rolls of fabric. Whether you choose to buy your material at the garden center or online, it needn’t cost the earth to keep those pesky weeds at bay.

Look out for dark material which better blocks the sunlight while at the same time darkens your soil. Most barriers are made from a synthetic geotextile. Some are laminated with polyethylene. Mesh allows the air and water your plants need to seep through without benefiting the weeds.

Plastic barriers are highly effective. By warming up the soil, the plants will be encouraged to grow while the weeds are efficiently strangled. UV-resistant plastic is available at a premium.

Most weed barriers will last for a year, perhaps even longer if you’re lucky and there’s not too much traffic on the lawn that might split the barrier.

Why Use a Weed Barrier?

Before spending your hard earned money on this equipment, take a look at a handful of reasons why it makes sense…

  • Barriers encourage other plants to grow. Weeds suck away the vitamins intended for them and, once they are gone, the plants will flourish. You should also enjoy stronger yields from your vegetables
  • Chemical weed killers are not environmentally friendly. At all. From spoiling the water in your soil through to harming vital microorganisms, chemicals wreak havoc. Go green with the best weed barrier
  • Do you have dogs at home? Using a weed barrier discourages them from digging up your garden. They will find the fabric too difficult to puncture and your lawn will thank you!
  • The permeable fabric used for weed barriers means that the plants and vegetables you want remain vibrant. The oxygen, water and nutrients they need can wick through to the roots and soil. Overall, your soil will remain nicely moist. This can save you from needing to constantly break out the hosepipe
  • Mulching is a neverending battle. Using a weed barrier helps your mulch to last longer so it’s a win-win. Simply pop it on top of the barrier and enjoy superior performance with less effort
  • If your garden is set on a hill, a weed barrier is a wise choice. Rather than soil slipping downward after heavy rain, the barrier will keep things in check nicely

What To Look For When Buying a Weed Barrier

Although they are extremely simple products, there are a handful of things to be aware of when you are looking for the best weed barrier…


Choosing to use a weed barrier rather than weed killer is half the battle won when it comes to considering the environment.

The last thing you want is to select a harmful weed barrier so make certain you buy carefully. It’s the resilient weeds you want to kill not your plants and vegetables so make sure the fabric is suitable. Any old roll of black plastic is not good enough.


The best weed barrier should be easy to install. You don’t want to be forced to call in a contractor and face added expense.

With many barriers, all you need is a pair of scissors and some patience. Don’t get this wrong and go for something that’s a grind to set up.


Whether or not you have plants under the barrier, protecting the soil is still crucial. You want the air and water it needs to get through. This is why the fabric on the weed barrier is breathable.

The whole object is the complete destruction of weeds with no damage done to the rest of your garden.


If you are taking the time, trouble and money to get yourself a weed barrier, you don’t need a cheap piece of junk you’ll need to replace every other month.

Look for a barrier that receives positive reviews and is built to last the distance.


Every buying decision involves price. You should think not only of the bottom line but of value for money in overall terms.

A cheap barrier that falls apart and needs replacing after a matter of weeks is false economy.

Buy the best weed barrier you can afford without compromising your budget.


Now it’s time to move on to our weed barrier reviews. If you take a little time and trouble, getting the best barrier is really not so difficult.

5 Best Weed Barrier Reviews

Product Name


Size (feet)

Durability (years)


Our Rating

Scotts 25-Year Pro Fabric

Scotts 25-Year Pro Fabric

3 x 150



Editor Choice

Dewitt 12-Year Weed Barrier Fabric 12YR450

Dewitt 12-Year Weed Barrier Fabric 12YR450

4 x 50




Easy Gardener 21041MJ 15 Year Landscape Fabric

Easy Gardener 21041MJ 15 Year Landscape Fabric

3 x 50




Mutual WF200 Polyethylene Woven Geotextile Fabric

WF200 Polyethylene Woven Geotextile Fabric

6 x 300

Not rated



Dewitt SBLT3300 Sunbelt Ground Cover Weed Barrier

Dewitt SBLT3300 Sunbelt Ground Cover Weed Barrier

3 x 300




If you check out any list of the best weed barriers, this offering from Scotts is always at or near the top.

When it comes to lawncare and gardening supplies, it pays to buy into a brand you trust. Scotts are a true industry heavyweight so you know you’ll be getting top quality at an affordable price.

You can buy this barrier in a number of configurations. The one we are reviewing gives you 3 x 150 feet of fabric so represents outstanding value.

This fabric from Scotts is incredibly durable. It’s 1.5 ounces in weight and has a feeling more of cloth than plastic.

Installation could not be easier. There’s no need to call in the professionals or break your back, just lie down your fabric and start kissing goodbye to the nuisance of weeds.

This barrier also works well on any patios, walkways or retaining walls so it’s truly multi-purpose.

The one thing to be aware of with this weed barrier is that it doesn’t quite let enough water through.

For a no-nonsense and affordable weed barrier that will not let you down, Scotts 25-Year Pro is a best-seller with good reason.

DeWitt have a deserved reputation for producing first-class products at very reasonable prices. This weed barrier is no exception.

This rugged fabric is rated to last 12 years. Much like Scotts 25-year material, it makes sense to focus on barriers that will last the distance.

Much more durable and heavier than much of the opposition, this makes perfect sense if you want to put down any mulch or gravel.

In terms of the fabric, this actually beats the Scotts barrier. It’s not woven and will allow all the moisture and air your plants need to pass through while suffocating the weeds. It is dense enough to prevent too much light getting through which in turn helps to kill weeds off.

This barrier is a cinch to install. The design stops the fabric from continually rolling up. It’s super-simple to cut and measures 4 x 50 feet.

If you want a really hard-hitting weed barrier without needing a bank loan, pop this great DeWitt barrier on your shortlist. It will deliver in fine style.

Another strong contender for the best weed barrier is this superb fabric from Easy Gardener.

If you are on the hunt for a cost-effective and capable barrier for the price of a couple of beers, this landscape fabric hits the spot.

The rolls are fairly light so unraveling them and installing the barrier is a piece of cake. Since it is a bare 3 feet wide, you’ll probably need some degree of overlapping if you want to treat a larger garden.

Although it feels lightweight, the fabric is surprisingly thick. It will not get ripped by stones and the right amount of water and air will make it through to the soil.

For dealing with smaller gardens or lining plant containers, this excellent barrier makes a smart budget choice if you want to see off the weeds while revitalizing your flowers and vegetables.

For anyone looking for the very best weed barrier money can buy, this awesome geotextile fabric from Mutual Industries is a must-see.

The roll is a generous 300 feet long and 6 feet wide. It’s not cheap but considering the amount of fabric you get and the quality, it’s actually not bad value at all.

Made from durable woven polyethylene, you can hold the soil in place nicely. These geotextile fabrics are also a wonderful alternative to using aggregate or sand as filters.

You can get up and running in no time with this barrier. Simply trim to fit and you’re good to go. Plain scissors will be fine. There is very little fraying which is reassuring.

As with all the best weed barriers, the mix is just right so that your soil gets all the nutrients it needs while the weeds are properly stifled.

If you have a little spare cash and you don’t mind spending out on a first-rate solution for getting rid of weeds, don’t overlook Mutual Industries.

Rounding out our weed barrier reviews is another offering from the ever-reliable DeWitt, the SBLT3300 ground cover.

For a cheap alternative to harmful herbicides, this weed barrier will not disappoint.

The air and water you need can permeate the fabric and it’s treated to be UV-resistant into the bargain.

Rated for 5 years assuming it’s in direct sunlight, you won’t need to worry about continually replacing the barrier.

Made from woven polypropylene, it’s dark enough to starve the weeds of sun without hurting your plants.

Note that when you cut the ends, it tends to fray and unravel slightly. One way to combat this is to use a lighter to singe the tattered ends.

For a heavy-duty weed barrier that will not let you down, this 3 x 300 feet roll from DeWitt might come last on our list but it punches above its weight.


We trust you’ve found our weed barrier reviews helpful in your quest for a beautifully manicured lawn.

While keeping weeds away can be tiresome, getting the best weed barrier certainly makes life easier.

Feel free to reach out with any queries or feedback. You are always welcome to share our articles on your social media.

Now banish those weeds!

igarden Planting

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This